The financing costs for European companies are beginning to show an upward trend following the adjustment of risk-free interest rates in the third quarter. In particular, the spreads on below-investment-grade bonds have surged in recent weeks, with a temporary widening of around 40 basis points on bonds rated B.
Credit fundamentals are facing structural pressures. This raises a question: do the corporate credit spreads, which remain at low levels, reflect true credit resilience or indicate that prices have not yet fully incorporated the risks?
At the issuer level, the median liquidity coverage ratios have improved since the second quarter, as companies continue to refinance their debt. However, two factors should be kept in mind:
- Firstly, the liquidity ratios of the bottom 10% of issuers are deteriorating.
- Secondly, the bottom quartile of issuers rated BB or below is largely dependent on the liquidity available in the markets to maintain adequate ratios.
Companies rated BB are particularly relevant, as they account for around 80% of the downgrades experienced so far this year.
Liquidity and credit quality maintain a constant feedback relationship: both depend on each other, although their deterioration tends to occur sequentially. The worsening of credit quality is usually a response to events related to business activity, while defaults tend to materialise as a result of a liquidity shortfall.
Therefore, we analyse liquidity in the specific context of each issuer's activity, and not merely as an external factor determined by the market. This implies understanding the conditions that determine each company's access to liquidity, conditions that are already changing. The European Central Bank indicates that bankruptcy filings in the eurozone are at their highest level since 2019, while banks are generally tightening their credit granting criteria. All this occurs in a context where many companies still rely heavily on short-term financing (chart 2).
Aspects we are closely monitoring
The interaction between liquidity and business risk takes on special importance in an environment like the current one, where structural pressures are accumulating on credit quality, especially among issuers with ratings below investment grade.
The structure of market liquidity is also relevant. Private credit markets with low credit ratings remain relatively opaque, which poses the risk that price signals provide less information and favour the emergence of different market practices between public and private markets. This includes phenomena that have made headlines, such as so-called "hidden defaults".
Average rating step adjustment for liquidity in each credit category.
- Credit risk may be accumulating at a faster pace than market signals reflect.
- As markets begin to readjust the cost of liquidity, we expect the following trends to become more pronounced:
- Analysis will shift away from focusing on liquidity to pay greater attention to companies' fundamentals and the extent to which these fundamentally depended, from the outset, on favourable liquidity conditions.
- Access to liquidity is becoming increasingly conditional, with stricter financing requirements, more demanding valuations, and a clearer differentiation between different levels of debt seniority.
- Sectors under credit pressure, such as energy-intensive industries or those exposed to changes in international competition, and sectors sensitive to valuation, including real estate, construction, and investment companies, are likely to experience greater divergence in their credit ratings. This is because pressures will affect issuers with less capacity to absorb them more intensely.
- Different markets will react differently, although only to a certain extent. All financial markets, whether equity, government bonds, private credit, or syndicated loans, rely on a similar set of assumptions about growth, interest rates, inflation, economic policy responses, and valuations.
- As these assumptions continue to change, the differentiation between issuers is likely to increasingly focus on their business risk profiles and their specific financing structures, whereas in recent years attention had primarily been directed towards the liquidity available in the markets. This would favour a persistent, and possibly accelerated, divergence in credit ratings.
Outlook
Corporate liquidity in Europe remains solid overall, although we are beginning to observe some signs of deterioration among the most vulnerable issuers. The market is starting to reassess the valuation of some of the fundamental components that determine corporate debt yields and, therefore, liquidity conditions.
This process occurs against a backdrop of increasing downgrades, which are disproportionately affecting issuers with poorer credit quality. In these cases, liquidity is likely to act as a factor that accelerates deterioration, especially when the abundance of financing has formed one of the pillars upon which these companies built their business plans and initial assumptions.
For the market as a whole, the issue is not so much the ability to refinance, as the continued availability of financing has allowed for the postponement of previously anticipated maturity concentrations and new debt issuances continue to show remarkable dynamism. However, the situation is different for certain issuers that are already experiencing difficulties. Especially in such heterogeneous European markets, it is likely that debt restructurings aimed at freeing up liquidity will become increasingly common in the medium term.
This outlook is also supported by our analysis: cash flow coverage ranks among the three main weaknesses of our portfolio of rated European companies, only behind lack of diversification and increased leverage. This situation is likely to worsen as both business conditions and access to liquidity tighten, which will drive new downward pressures on credit ratings.
In the longer term, it remains uncertain whether market prices will begin to reflect greater credit risk among corporate issuers and, if so, how quickly. In recent years, numerous fundamental assumptions about how markets operate have been redefined, from the degree of interconnectedness of financial markets globally to the levels of price transparency across their various segments. These new dynamics have yet to be truly tested in times of stress.
In this context, all signs point to increasing credit tensions for European companies, although their effects will be transmitted unevenly across sectors, regions, and market segments with different liquidity conditions. It will be essential to closely monitor these feedback dynamics as the assumptions underpinning the markets continue to change.