Spain is coming apart at the seams

Ernest Hemingway wrote in “The Sun Also Rises” how one goes bankrupt, the formula is simple: “little by little and then suddenly.” It serves to describe and diagnose what is happening in Spain. We have jumped from the objective: “that Spain works” (a mantra of Felipe González to achieve government in 1982) to a situation in which Spain “does not work.”

Let us remember Vargas Llosa as we talk about writers, when or how did Spain get ruined? Well, that’s it, “little by little and then suddenly.” Little by little cutting back and skimping on investments in the maintenance of public capital, roads, railways, hospital and educational facilities… and then suddenly we are faced with the wall of “it doesn’t work.” Not only cuts and adjustments, but also incompetence and inefficiency of those managing that public capital. 

Poor management due to partisanship, by sidelining merit and suitability when assigning positions (responsibilities) in the public sector. When party affiliation (not even ideological or political), the party card, friends… are the fundamental criteria for appointments, the “little by little” criterion is fulfilled, leading to the “suddenly” of a disastrous slope.

The latest railway catastrophe perfectly illustrates the fatalism of “little by little”; delays in replacement investments, in the renewal of signalling and control systems, cuts in well-trained human resources… and “suddenly,” the catastrophe. And something similar in the failed response to the storm that devastated Valencia. The cuts and adjustments resulting from the fiscal crisis of 2010 did not only materialise in social spending; public capital, its maintenance, and new investments also suffered. And that comes at a cost, especially when managed poorly. 

Four years without budgets, with extensions and reallocations of spending due to urgency, necessity, or whim, does not come for free. Twenty-first century Spain is coming apart at the seams, little suit and much body, the number of residents has jumped from 40 to 50 million, not to mention the increasing influx of tourists who also require public services. Providing housing, care, infrastructure… to more people requires more investment, more equipment. And that has not happened; the rulers have postponed studying demographics, noticing changes, and preventing their consequences. 

The image and reality of Spain have been losing ground throughout this century; from the exemplary process of democratic transition, admired by both friends and foes, we have moved to a situation of increasing scandals over corruption and the poor functioning of essential public services. Not everything is deteriorating; exports are performing better than ever, and behind this phenomenon is the good performance of many competitive and innovative companies. There has never been so many and so efficient. 

A good part of the public administration offers results as good as or better than those of other countries in the region; but it is not enough for the services that citizens expect and demand. On the eve of a change of government, with high possibilities of radical change, it is a good time to point out that the main task of the new government can only be to reverse the trend, to prevent that sliding from “little by little” to “suddenly.”

Fernando González Urbaneja
Director of CONSEJEROS with more than 40 years of experience in economic journalism. He was the founder and editor-in-chief of El País, general editor of the business newspaper Cinco Días, and is a professor at Carlos III University. He has been president of the Madrid Press Association and the Spanish Federation of Press Associations, and is a member of the Complaints Commission of the Spanish Press.

Most read